to more accurate diagnosis biopsies
Physicians more accurately assessed the severity of cancer in a breast when they conducted needle biopsies with a higher gauge needle the size of a drinking straw and equipped with a vacuum suction device, a study by a Yale researcher shows.
When using this technique, the physicians underestimated the disease's severity in less than 10% of the cases. This compares to an 18% rate of underestimation using a smaller 14-gauge needle and automatic gun to extract breast tissue for testing for cancer, says the principal investigator, Liane Philpotts, assistant professor of diagnostic radiology at Yale School of Medicine.
"We looked at how often we did not fully diagnose the cancer," says Philpotts of the study published in the American Journal of Roentgenology. "It's not that cancers are missed. These are cases where we realized there was something wrong, but underestimated the severity of it."
Stereotactic core needle biopsy is widely used in place of surgical biopsy for the diagnosis of lesions of the breast originally diagnosed in mammograms. Although the needle biopsy has been shown to be highly accurate in diagnosing benign and malignant breast disease, it can underestimate cancer. This often results in the need for more surgery.
The retrospective study reviewed biopsies performed between October 1996 and March 1999 using an 11-gauge vacuum suction device. The vacuum suction device is an alternative to the automatic gun technique. Using either 14-gauge or 11-gauge probes, it can obtain core samples that are substantially larger than those obtained with the 14-gauge needle and automatic gun.
The study revealed that out of 753 biopsies in 688 patients, 178 were identified as cases of atypical ductal hyperplasia, or abnormal cell growth, and ductal carcinoma in situ, or invasive disease.
The cases were then correlated to identify cases in which cancer was underestimated. Underestimated cancer cases were those in which either carcinoma was not diagnosed or invasive disease was not diagnosed. Of the 178 cases, 158 cases of cancer were ultimately diagnosed. Underestimation occurred in 15 cases, or 9.5% of the time.
The underestimation rate for calcification was 18%; for atypical, ductal hyperplasia, 26%; for masses, 1.6%; and for ductal carcinoma in situ, 18%.
No underestimations were found among cases in which the entire lesion identified in a mammogram was removed during the vacuum suction biopsy.
Philpotts says that although underestimation still occurs with the vacuum suction device, the data in the study helps to clarify which cases are more likely to result in underestimation. Underestimation is significantly more likely to occur in cases of calcification than in cases of masses.
The senior author of the study was Irena Tocino, professor and chief of breast imaging, diagnostic radiology; Carol Lee, associate professor, diagnostic radiology; Laura Horvath, assistant professor, diagnostic radiology; Robert Lange, associate professor, diagnostic radiology; and Darryl Carter, professor of pathology.
-- By Jacqueline Weaver
T H I S
Bulletin Home
W E E K ' SS T O R I E S
Study says 1 in 3 doctors don't go to the doctor
Allen Forte Chair honors renowned Yale musical theorist
Alumnus Thomas Golden creates chair in engineering
Shepardson tackling life on the gridiron in Women's Professional Football League
Author McCourt shares memories of his teaching days
Harry Adams will fill in as the acting dean of Divinity School
Event explores encounters between U.S., Middle East
Record-setting Bulldog garners regional awards
Czech Republic honors Demetz for scholarship
MEDICAL CENTER NEWSResearchers find two genes responsible for emphysema
Estrogen deprivation kills the brain's dopamine cells, researchers have found
Advanced nursing home care extends life of elderly with cancer
Larger-needle breast biopsies lead to more accurate diagnosis biopsies
Unsafe home environment is not leading cause of falls among elderly, study finds
Elder Life Program helps prevent patients' mental decline in hospitals
Yale doctor is first to use new imaging technique
Alumna wins major prize for science research
Stained Glass: Photos from around the campus
Program targets speeders
'Angelic' Russian choir to perform holiday carols
Multimedia work combines the natural and the technological to tell a tale of love
In the News
Yale Scoreboard
|Visiting on Campus|
Calendar of Events|Bulletin Board
Classified Ads|Search Archives|Production Schedule|Bulletin Staff
Public Affairs Home|News Releases|
E-Mail Us|Yale Home Page