Two surgical procedures, one invasive and the other much less so, for premature infants with intestinal perforation due to necrotizing enterocolitis (NEC) produce virtually identical results, according to a School of Medicine study published May 25 in the New England Journal of Medicine.
A significant aspect of the study is that it is the first multi-center randomized controlled trial to be completed comparing two operations in children, says the lead author, Dr. Larry Moss, chief of pediatric surgery in the Department of Surgery.
"Surgery is one of the most dramatic and potentially life-altering events in a patient's medical life, yet a remarkable amount of surgical practice is based upon historical tradition rather than scientific evidence," Moss says. "The vast majority of research on surgical conditions involves a single group of surgeons reporting upon their personal experience at one institution.
"This report," he continues, "argues against conventional wisdom that randomized studies cannot be effectively utilized to compare treatments for acutely life-threatening conditions. It proves that despite the biases against surgical trials, they can be completed with appropriate commitment by surgeons and their institutions."
NEC is a severe inflammatory disease of the intestine afflicting 5,000 to 10,000 premature infants in the United States each year. In its most severe form, NEC results in perforation of part of the intestine, which requires emergency surgery that can be life-saving.
For more than 25 years surgeons have used two radically different operations for these babies. The first and more aggressive, laparotomy and bowel resection, involves a large abdominal incision with removal of all affected intestine and creation of a stoma, which means bringing the end of the intestine through the abdomen to drain into a bag. The alternative option, peritoneal drainage, involves making a one-quarter-inch incision in the lower abdomen and placing a small drain allowing egress of stool and pus from the abdomen without removing any intestine.
The trial led by Moss included 117 premature infants at 15 leading pediatric academic medical centers from the United States and Canada. When a baby developed perforated NEC at a study site, parents were counseled by the operating surgeons and offered enrollment into the trial. If they agreed, the operation their child received was assigned randomly.
"The study found that patient survival and other major outcomes for the two drastically different operations were virtually identical," he says. "After 30 years of debate over which procedure is best, the first true scientific experiment addressing this question suggests that the method of the surgery may not be the important aspect of treatment."
As a next step, Moss is working with six academic medical centers to collect clinical and biological information for a database to identify which babies with NEC are at greatest risk of perforation. The team is collaborating with other researchers who are developing promising new therapies that can be tested in this targeted group of patients.
"Since the study compared the most aggressive surgical treatment with the least invasive and found no difference, it appears unlikely that ongoing focus on the details of the operation is likely to improve survival in these patients,"
he says.
Moss also has developed and tested a set of clinical research reporting guidelines for surgery that revealed there was a lack of evidence for many surgical procedures in children. The tool was then validated on a large sample of several hundred studies. As a result of this work, the Journal of Pediatric Surgery has adopted the guidelines and is using them for all clinical research published in the journal.
-- By Jacqueline Weaver
T H I S
W E E K ' SS T O R I E S
PBS news anchor elected as trustee
Ceremony formally marks Rose Center opening
New Peabody hall offering high-tech lessons about Earth and space
Scientists believe that green tea may be key to 'Asian paradox'
COMMENCEMENT 2006
University celebrates its 305th graduation
Baccalaureate Address
Honorary Degrees
Other student awards
ENDOWED PROFESSORSHIPS
James Gustave Speth named Sara Shallenberger Brown Professor
James Baron comes to SOM as the William S. Beinecke Professor
New exhibit asks: What did Shakespeare really look like?
Samples from ocean floor at the North Pole yield clues . . .
MEDICAL SCHOOL NEWS
Nation's first manual for treating radiation victims developed
Animals may provide warning of bioterrorist attack, say researchers
Researchers uncovering clues to drug resistance in ovarian cancer
Scientists find way to use intestinal cells to stop . . .
Study: Less-invasive surgery equally effective for infants . . .Scientists unlocking key to molecular basis of debilitating pain . . .
Arts & Ideas festival adds a dash of New Orleans spice
Art & Architecture Library taking up temporary residence on Crown Street
Forum explores governmental budgetary processes in China
Library events celebrate aviator and author Anne Morrow Lindberg
Making the Grade
Uncovering Ingrained Attitudes About Obesity
Nursing School research shows ideas about ideal weight . . .
Rudd Center survey reveals that many people would give up . . .
Artist's exhibit at Slifka Center will examine complexity of faith
Jaroslav Pelikan, renowned scholar of church history
Event will bring bellringers from near and far to the Yale campus
Gigantic balloon creatures to invade Hall of Dinosaurs
Celebrated performer to teach summer flute institute
Drama production will highlight work by New Haven students
Reading aloud
Campus Notes
Bulletin Home|Visiting on Campus|Calendar of Events|In the News
Bulletin Board|Classified Ads|Search Archives|Deadlines
Bulletin Staff|Public Affairs|News Releases|
E-Mail Us|Yale Home