be a sign of their compassion
The vast majority of Yale medical students cried as a result of emotional encounters with patients during their first year of clinical rotations, according to an essay by a School of Medicine faculty member published in the Journal of the American Medical Association.
The essay by Dr. Nancy R. Angoff, associate dean for student affairs, also noted that the experience of strong emotions can have an important impact on their education as physicians.
Angoff, an assistant professor of medicine, for two years surveyed all Yale students at the end of their required third-year clinical rotations, asking them: "During your clincial rotations, did you ever cry?" Of the 182 students polled, 133 said they had cried at least once, 30 had been on the verge of crying and 19 denied crying. Many, however, reported that they felt isolated by the experience or hid their crying.
In her JAMA essay, "Crying in the Curriculum," Angoff wrote, "Medical educators who fail to look for or listen to stories of crying may be missing an opportunity to have an impact on students' emotional lives and their development as caring physicians."
According to Angoff, "Crying is extremely prevalent in medical schools. I don't think it is unique to Yale, but people rarely realize it. We need to recognize it and use it in the clinical setting to teach students to become more caring, compassionate and thoughtful physicians."
Students told her stories of their crying, several of which she recounts in her JAMA essay, which appeared in the Sept. 5 issue. Students were often worried that their crying would appear unprofessional, especially in a field that has traditionally emphasized the need for emotional restraint.
"Most felt reluctant to have others on their rotation team know they had cried," she said. "We should let students know that not only is it normal and okay, but it may be a sign of a valuable capacity for compassion."
-- By Marc Wortman
T H I S
Bulletin Home
W E E K ' SS T O R I E S
SOM competition to help nonprofits
Student wins chance to meet Nobel laureates
NYT reporter explains politics of science
Astronomers suggest that 'slow dance' between black holes may power quasars
Levin discusses patent law in meetings with leaders
Burns' talks about Mark Twain and the American spirit
Innovations make the 'impractical' possible, says economist
Renowned journalist Tom Friedman to visit as Poynter Fellow
Talks by author Rushdie to explore changed nature of frontiers
ENDOWED PROFESSORSHIPSPanel to probe questions surrounding Enron's collapse
Conference pays tribute to judge who was committed to racial justice
Trustee Barrington D. Parker sworn in to federal court
Aboard the Cultural Caravan
Exhibition honors memory of Dr. Donald Cohen
Conference to celebrate 'Langston Hughes and His World'
MEDICAL SCHOOL NEWSGrant supports research into the debilitating disease of narcolepsy
Dr. Robert Berliner dies; former medical school dean . . .
EPH researcher documents war's damaging effects
Crying by medical students may be a sign of their compassion
Master architects inspire students to design for the future
Conference looks at the 'faces' of Japanese cinema
Library sponsoring program on Islamic civilization and identity
Campus Notes
|Visiting on Campus|Calendar of Events|In the News|Bulletin Board
Yale Scoreboard|Classified Ads|Search Archives|Deadlines
Bulletin Staff|Public Affairs Home|News Releases|
E-Mail Us|Yale Home Page