Yale Bulletin and Calendar

May 11, 2007|Volume 35, Number 28|Two-Week Issue


BULLETIN HOME

VISITING ON CAMPUS

CALENDAR OF EVENTS

IN THE NEWS

BULLETIN BOARD

CLASSIFIED ADS


SEARCH ARCHIVES

DEADLINES

DOWNLOAD FORMS

BULLETIN STAFF


PUBLIC AFFAIRS HOME

NEWS RELEASES

E-MAIL US


YALE HOME PAGE


The reproductive organs of male and female waterfowl such as the ducks pictured here have co-evolved to create an "exquisite anti-lock-and-key system." As males developed longer phalluses, females' anatomy evolved to give them greater control over reproduction.



Co-evolution of genitalia in waterfowl
reveals 'war between the sexes'

A team of biologists at Yale and the University of Sheffield discovered anatomical details about the female reproductive tract in waterfowl that indicate that male and female anatomy have co-evolved in a "sexual arms race."

In most birds, copulation consists of a simple, and rather chaste, "cloacal kiss," note the researchers, but avian diversity includes a few ancient lineages that retained the grooved phallus found in their reptilian ancestors. Among living birds, the waterfowl are one of the lineages that still have the grooved phallus. Waterfowl are also distinct in having great diversity among different species in the length and ornamentation of the phallus.

This diversity in waterfowl phallus size and shape has been previously explained as a result of sperm competition. Scientists speculated that sperm from males with a longer phallus had a competitive edge over sperm from those less well-endowed. This report in the online journal PLoS ONE shows that there is a lot more to the story.

"As part of a research program on the evolution of the avian phallus, I was curious to know if there were consequences to female ducks of the tremendous anatomical variation found in the male phallus," says the lead author Patricia Brennan, a joint postdoctoral researcher in ecology and evolutionary biology at Yale and animal and plant sciences at University of Sheffield in the United Kingdom.

Her study is a complementary exploration of the anatomy of the female reproductive tract, called the oviduct or vagina, which is usually very simple and similar among birds. Brennan found two unexpectedly complex and entirely novel structures that all seem designed for one purpose -- to selectively exclude the male phallus.

In most birds, the oviduct is a simple tube, but in some waterfowl, the tube has unique sacs and spirals. The sacs are out-pocketings in the sides of the tube that are just inside the opening of the oviduct.

"They appear to function as 'dead-ends,' or false passages," says Brennan. "If the phallus were to enter one of these sacs, it would not progress further into the oviduct where it would deposit sperm more effectively."

The second structural novelty of the female is a series of tight, clock-wise spirals in the tubular oviduct. "Interestingly," says Yale ornithologist and co-author Richard Prum, "the male phallus is also a spiral, but it twists in the opposite, counter-clockwise, direction. So, the twists in the oviduct appear designed to exclude the opposing twists of the male phallus. It's an exquisite anti-lock-and-key system."

The number of sacs and spirals in the reproductive tract of various female waterfowl correlates strongly with the length of the male phallus. Comparing the phallus size and oviduct shape in 14 different species of ducks and geese, the authors show that the genitalia of males and females have dynamically co-evolved with one another.

According to the study, in various independent lineages of ducks, females developed more elaborate oviducts as males evolved longer phalluses. In other lineages, females lost oviduct complexity as the phallus evolved toward smaller size.

This dynamic evolution, Brennan hypothesizes, suggests that the female waterfowl have evolved these unique anatomical features as physical counter-measures to evade male attempts to assert control over reproduction.

According to Prum, "Despite the fact that most waterfowl form monogamous pairs, forced copulations by other males -- the avian equivalent of rape -- are common in many waterfowl. The length of the phallus of a species is strongly correlated with the frequency of forced copulations."

Brennan notes, "In response to male attempts to force their paternity on females, female waterfowl may be able to assert their own behavioral and anatomical means of controlling who fathers their offspring."

The authors theorize that elaborate phalluses and female oviducts have co-evolved in a dynamic response to one another -- that phalluses have developed to be more elaborate than the means of excluding them, and vice versa.

These physical barriers, the authors speculate, are easily overcome when females cooperate during copulation; they only function to exclude unwanted advances.

Brennan is pursuing these results with further exploration of the development and evolution of genitalia in birds. "I am sure there are more surprises out there," she says. Her future research will explore why different lineages of ducks and other birds vary in breeding biology and genital complexity.

The research team also included Tim Birkhead at University of Sheffield, Kevin McCracken and Robert Wilson of the University of Alaska, and Michael Sorenson of Boston University. The research was funded by a postdoctoral fellowship to Brennan from the National Science Foundation.

-- By Janet Rettig Emanuel


T H I SW E E K ' SS T O R I E S

Co-evolution of genitalia in waterfowl reveals 'war between the sexes'

Study of Galápagos tortoises' DNA may locate mate for 'Lonesome George'

Eighteen new Yale World Fellows named

Health clinic staff among the winners of Elm-Ivy Awards

Bringing a philosophical perspective to palliative care

University breaks ground for its 'most green building'

Child Study Center recognized for leadership in autism research

Yale senior Rebekah Emanuel wins Simon Fellowship for Noble Purpose

Using molecular 'nanosyringe,' researchers demonstrate . . .

Irish writer's play about Siamese twins wins Yale Drama Series award

When it comes to grades, giving is no easier than receiving, says panel

Talents of drama students showcased in Carlotta Festival

Biophysicist Steitz honored for ribosome research with Gairdner Award

CCL renovations on schedule; lawn to be used for Commencement

Project aims to improve financial services for those living in poverty

Pastoral leadership skills are focus of Center for Faith and Culture event

MacMillan Center honors the work of three Yale faculty members

Yale has highest number of sports teams honored . . .

WORKSPACE ENHANCEMENTS AT THE SCHOOL OF MEDICINE

Campus Notes


Bulletin Home|Visiting on Campus|Calendar of Events|In the News

Bulletin Board|Classified Ads|Search Archives|Deadlines

Bulletin Staff|Public Affairs|News Releases| E-Mail Us|Yale Home