for post-heart-attack diagnostic procedure
In the first large national study on the topic, Yale researchers found physicians of both sexes were more likely to refer men than women for cardiac catheterization, a diagnostic procedure used to assess blood flow to the heart, after a heart attack.
The study suggests that the higher rates of cardiac catheterization among men do not simply reflect the sexist prejudices of male doctors toward female patients. Whatever factors influence this pattern of care appear to involve both male and female physicians, say the researchers.
Published in the Dec. 12 issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association, the study showed that elderly women were 10% less likely to undergo cardiac catheterization after a heart attack than men, even after accounting for clinical differences between men and women.
"These data provide strong evidence that women and men are treated differently after they have had a heart attack," said senior author Dr. Harlan Krumholz, associate professor of medicine at the School of Medicine and director of the Yale-New Haven Hospital Center for Outcomes Research and Evaluation.
The issue of disparities in health care and outcomes has received significant attention. However, Krumholz noted that most investigators have focused on documenting differences in care by sex; this investigation, however, extends previous work by examining the influence of gender differences among physicians on choices in care, he notes
"Concerns that gender differences in procedure use primarily reflect the behavior of male physicians are not supported by these findings," says the study's first author Saif Rathore, research fellow in the Department of Internal Medicine. "Gender differences in cardiac catheterization rates were also present among patients who received care from female physicians."
Using data from the Cooperative Cardiovascular Project, a federal initiative to improve the care of Medicare patients hospitalized for acute myocardial infarction in 1994 and 1995, the team evaluated whether differences between men and women in the use of cardiac catheterization varied according to the gender of their attending physician.
They found that of 49,583 men and 54,648 women with acute myocardial infarction, physicians of both genders referred women for cardiac catheterization about 10% less often than men. The authors note that while the study cannot preclude the existence of sexual discrimination or prejudice, "it does suggest that if physician factors contribute to gender differences in cardiac catheterization use, be it by perceptions of heart disease in women or other attitudes, then these factors are apparently common to both male physicians and female physicians," notes coauthor Jersey Chen, resident in the department of radiology at the University of Pennsylvania.
Krumholz says the findings underscore the complexity of this issue. "We did find a difference in the rates of cardiac catheterization that could not be explained by gender differences in the clinical characteristics of the patients, their physicians or the type of hospitals where they received treatment. We could not illuminate the reason for these differences."
The authors also found that patients treated by male physicians were 6% more likely to undergo cardiac catheterization than patients treated by female physicians. "It is unclear what factors may result in male physicians referring more of their patients for cardiac catheterization than female physicians, but data concerning other medical tests have shown that male physicians and female physicians can refer patients at different rates," notes Rathore. "Clearly, additional research is needed to confirm this finding," he said.
In addition to Krumholz, Rathore and Chen, the study's authors include Martha Radford, associate professor of medicine; Yongfei Wang, statistical analyst; and Dr. Viola Vaccarino, researcher at Emory University School of Medicine.
-- By Karen Peart
T H I S
Bulletin Home
W E E K ' SS T O R I E S
Yale boasts five new Rhodes, Marshall Scholars
Internationally renowned journalist examines causes of terrorists' rage
Former U.S. ambassador discusses role of leaders in Israel-Palestine clash
Sternberg to focus on students' rights as head of APA
DeVane Lectures to look at love, law in Cervantes' works
Famed architect Maya Lin discusses how her works are inspired . . .
In Focus: International Spouses & Partners at Yale
Scholar urges expansion of efforts to save giant pandas
MEDICAL SCHOOL NEWSScreening program seeks to prevent death of young athletes
Research shows doctors refer fewer women for post-heart-attack . . .
Long-term study proves value of antiepileptic drug
Scientists discover how deadly bacteria infect cells
Roundup of recent health-related discoveries
New Yale-Griffin Center Initiatives
Piano performance piece to open Yale Rep series
Yale Rep announces spring line-up of plays
Happy Holidays! Season's Greetings from the Staff . . .
Ethics of health care will be explored in ISPS talk
Yale athletes to offer free basketball clinic to neighborhood youths
A window to treasure
'Blood and Race' in the U.S. is topic of talk
Yale Books in Brief
Campus Notes
|Visiting on Campus|Calendar of Events|In the News|Bulletin Board
Yale Scoreboard|Classified Ads|Search Archives|Deadlines
Bulletin Staff|Public Affairs Home|News Releases|
E-Mail Us|Yale Home Page